Select Auto Protect vs. 1800Warranty

Select Auto Protect vs. 1800Warranty
Select Auto Protect / Blog / Select Auto Protect vs. 1800Warranty

An extended warranty is an optional service contract for drivers to cover the cost of repairs and maintenance of a vehicle after the manufacturer’s warranty has expired. It gives a sense of securityto car owners by reducing the financial burden of unexpected maintenance, especially for high-end cars that may require costly repairs.

Several companies offer extended warranty services, and in this blog post, we’ll be comparing two of them: Select Auto Protect, based in Delaware, and 1800Warranty, based in New Jersey.

Select Auto Protect offers various coverage plans for both new and used cars, with options for bumper-to-bumper coverage, powertrain coverage, and even hybrid and electric vehicle coverage. They also offer a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance.

1800Warranty, on the other hand, offers a range of coverage options for vehicles up to 20 years old or with up to 200,000 miles. They have customizable plans to fit individual needs, and their coverage includes parts and labor costs for covered repairs.

So, let’s take a closer look at the services offered by Select Auto Protect and 1800Warranty, comparing their pricing, coverage options, and customer service to help you decide which company is best for your extended warranty needs.

Select Auto Protect vs. 1800Warranty: Overview

Before delving into the specifics of Select Auto Protect and 1800Warranty, let’s take a look at a comparison chart that outlines each company’s features:

 Select Auto Protect1800Warranty
Year Established20202020
24/7 ClaimsYesYes
Unlimited Service CallsYesYes
Deductible$100Up to $250
Coverage for Old VehiclesYesOnly 2000+ model year and up to 200,000 miles
Money Back GuaranteeYes (30-Day)Yes (30-Day)
Cancellation PolicyFull refund if canceled within 30 days of purchaseFull refund if canceled within 30 days of purchase
Roadside AssistanceIncluded in all plansIncluded in all plans
Additional Benefits

Trip interruption benefits

Towing coverage

More experience in the industry

Paid option to protect rims and tires
Sample Contract AvailableYesNot available

Select Auto Protect Overview

Having been in the industry for over 30 years, Select Auto Protect has established a solid reputation as an extended warranty company. A unique benefit of their services is the unlimited service calls, allowing customers to seek assistance as often as needed without incurring additional charges. Additionally, customers can choose their preferred mechanic, as Select Auto Protect accepts any ASE-certified technician across the United States. The company also protects against unexpected repairs and maintenance expenses, covering a wide range of car makes and models.

1800Warranty Overview

1800Warranty is an extended warranty company based in Parsippany-Troy Hills, New Jersey, that pays the repair shop directly for covered repairs, providing hassle-free service for customers. The company also boasts a lightning-fast claims turnaround time, ensuring that customers can complete their repairs quickly and efficiently.

Select Auto Protect vs. 1800Warranty: Coverage

Here is a summary of the plans for Select Auto Protect and 1800Warranty.

Select Auto Protect Coverage

Select Auto Protect has various extended warranty plans that offer customers comprehensive coverage. The company’s Select Silver plan is a cost-effective option that covers essential components such as the engine, transmission, cooling system, electrical system, and brakes. Customers enrolled in the Select Silver plan also gain access to the company’s gas refill, rental car programs, and roadside assistance.

For those who desire more coverage, the Select Gold plan includes all the features of the Select Silver plan, with additional lock-out protection and coverage for the steering system. The Select Platinum plan is Select Auto Protect’s top-tier contract, offering all the benefits of the Gold and Silver plans and extra coverage for the AC and cooling system, ABS brakes, suspension, and more.

 Select PlatinumSelect GoldSelect Silver
Cooling Systemxxx
Brake Systemxxx
Electrical Systemxxx
Drive Axlexxx
Trip Interruptionxxx
Gas Refillxxx
Roadside Assistancexxx
Rental Carxxx
Lock Outxx 
Steering Systemxx 
ABS Brakesx  
AC Systemx  
Heating Systemx  
Fuel Systemx  
Front Suspensionx  
Back Suspensionx  

1800Warranty Coverage

1800Warranty offers four comprehensive coverage options: Power Protect, Advantage Protect, Ultra Protect, and Elite Protect. Each plan provides a different level of coverage for repairs and maintenance, ranging from basic to extensive. Customers can also choose to include tire and wheel coverage with any of the four plans. This ensures customers can select a plan that fits their needs and budget, providing peace of mind against unexpected repair and maintenance expenses.

Customer Reviews

In order to get a more accurate picture of what coverage with each company is like, here are several customer reviews for both Select Auto Protect and 1800Warranty.

Select Auto Protect Reviews

On Trustpilot, Select Auto Protect has a 4.5 out of 5 star rating out of over 150 reviews. Here’s what customers say about Select Auto Protect:

“Excellent service, outstanding support. Representative was incredible and immediately addressed all my issues. Coverage was complete and timely, less than an hour! This is by far, the best auto warranty company in the U.S., and I’ve referred a number of friends and family.

Thank you Select Auto, you have a great team!” – Boris Bergus

“This company was not pushy and everything they said about the warranty is what I’m seeking for. What’d better is that we all don’t have thousand of dollars so the monthly is were it’s at and being number 1 of the top 20 warranty companies is were I feel comfortable. AND my rep is so helpful and went beyond to get me what I need.” – Souren Sevadjian

1800Warranty Reviews

Here are several Trustpilot 1800Warranty reviews. The company currently has a rating of 4.3 out of 50 reviews.

“1800 Is the best. Very reliable professional. I like Ms Judy. She broke it down to me so i can fully understand. Thank you.” – L. Wallace

“Fantastic service! Judianne was super helpful in answering all of my questions and even went out of her way to assist me!” – Kristina


After analyzing the services and benefits of both Select Auto Protect and 1800Warranty, it is clear that Select Auto Protect emerges as the superior extended warranty company. With over 30 years of industry experience, Select Auto Protect offers comprehensive coverage plans for new and used vehicles. Additionally, their unlimited service calls, flexible mechanic options, and 24/7 roadside assistance provide customers with peace of mind and efficient service. While 1800Warranty also offers valuable coverage options, their lack of transparency regarding pricing and contract terms and their limited coverage for high-mileage vehicles make them a less attractive option for customers. In conclusion, Select Auto Protect stands out as the best choice for those seeking reliable, affordable, and comprehensive extended warranty coverage for their vehicles.

Free Quote
No Hidden Fees
Cancel Anytime

We made it easy for you, just follow 3 simple steps

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top