Select Auto Protect vs. Fenix Protect

Select Auto Protect vs. Fenix Protect
Select Auto Protect / Blog / Select Auto Protect vs. Fenix Protect

If your vehicle’s original warranty has expired, it would be wise to invest in an extended warranty option. This type of coverage can securely protect you from the unexpected and often expensive costs of maintenance and repairs. In addition to giving you a peace of mind in case of emergencies, it also allows you to avoid unexpected costs.

Select Auto Protect is just one of several providers of extended car warranties. When opting for a new contract, comparing all the options you have is crucial. This article will compare Select Auto Protect to one of our top competitors – Fenix Protect.

Select Auto Protect vs. Fenix Protect: Overview

Before delving into the specifics of Select Auto Protect and Fenix Protect car warranty plans, let’s take a look at a comparison chart that outlines each company’s features:

 Select Auto ProtectFenix Protect
Experience in the Industry30+ years10+ years
24/7 ClaimsYesDuring business hours only
Unlimited Service CallsYesYes
Number of Plans Offered37, coverage depends on the mileage
Money Back GuaranteeYes (30-Day)Yes (30-Day)
Cancellation PolicyFull refund if canceled within 30 days of purchaseFull refund if canceled within 30 days of purchase
Roadside AssistanceIncluded in all plansIncluded in all plans
Additional Benefits

Trip interruption benefits

Towing coverage

Gas refill services

Payment plans

Flat tire changes

Vehicle fluid delivery

Sample Contract AvailableYesNot available

Select Auto Protect Overview

Select Auto Protect aims to eliminate the anxiety of unexpected auto repairs and maintenance. The company offers three plans, each allowing customers to have their vehicle serviced at any ASE (National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence) location across the country. Unlike other extended warranty providers, Select Auto Protect does not require an onsite inspection before taking the car to the mechanic. The only thing that customers need to do is call the customer service team and provide their VIN number and current odometer reading.

Customers are only responsible for their deductible at the auto repair shop. If customers call the Select Auto Protect customer service team, a representative will provide payment information to the repair facility for the remainder of the bill. Additionally, Select Auto Protect provides 24/7 claims processing for all customers and offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Select Auto Protect Warranty: Pros and Cons

Below are some of the main advantages and disadvantages of Select Auto Protect:

Coverage for vehicles of all agesNo mobile app
Roadside assistanceLimited number of plans
Seamless reimbursement and repair payment process 
No onsite inspection required 

Fenix Protect Overview

Fenix Protect is an extended warranty company based in Addison, Texas, with over 10 years of experience. The company offers a range of protection plans for new and used vehicles, with two for new vehicles and five for used cars. These plans provide extended coverage beyond the manufacturer’s warranty, offering peace of mind to customers who want to protect their investment in their vehicle.

Fenix Protect: Pros and Cons

Roadside assistanceUnclear info and hard to navigate website
Seven coverage plansLower Trustpilot rating

Select Auto Protect vs. Fenix Protect: Coverage

Here are summaries of the plans and coverage for Select Auto Protect and Fenix Protect.

Select Auto Protect Coverage

Select Auto Protect offers three extended warranty plans that provide comprehensive coverage. Select Silver plan is an affordable option with protection for your engine, transmission, cooling system, electrical, and brakes. Customers enrolled in Select Silver also receive access to our roadside assistance, gas refill, and rental car programs.

For even more coverage, there is Select Gold plan, which includes all the features of Select Silver plus lock-out protection and coverage for your steering system. The top-tier contract, Select Platinum, has all the benefits of Gold and Silver and coverage for your AC and cooling system, ABS brakes, suspension, and more.

 Select PlatinumSelect GoldSelect Silver
Cooling Systemxxx
Brake Systemxxx
Electrical Systemxxx
Drive Axlexxx
Trip Interruptionxxx
Gas Refillxxx
Roadside Assistancexxx
Rental Carxxx
Lock Outxx 
Steering Systemxx 
ABS Brakesx  
AC Systemx  
Heating Systemx  
Fuel Systemx  
Front Suspensionx  
Back Suspensionx  

Fenix Protect Coverage

Fenix Protect provides a variety of coverage plans for both new and used vehicles. With seven plans, customers can choose from two options for new vehicles – Triple Diamond and Double Diamond – and five for used cars – Double Diamond, Diamond, Emerald, Rube, and Sapphire. In addition to comprehensive protection, each plan includes roadside assistance, which covers jump starts, lockout assistance, flat tire changes, vehicle fluid delivery, and towing.

New Vehicle Protection PlansUsed Vehicle Protection Plans
Triple Diamond – up to 70,000 milesDouble Diamond – up to 100,000 miles
Double Diamond – up to 80,000 milesDiamond – up to 125,000 miles
 Emerald – up to 150,000 miles
 Ruby – up to 175,000 miles
 Sapphire – up to 500,000 miles

Customer Reviews

To get a more accurate picture of what coverage with each company is like, here are several customer reviews for both Select Auto Protect and Fenix Protect.

Select Auto Protect Reviews

On Trustpilot, Select Auto Protect has a 4.5 out of 5 star rating out of over 150 reviews. Here’s what customers say about Select Auto Protect:

“Excellent service, outstanding support. Representative was incredible and immediately addressed all my issues. Coverage was complete and timely, less than an hour! This is by far, the best auto warranty company in the U.S., and I’ve referred a number of friends and family.

Thank you Select Auto, you have a great team!” – Boris Bergus

“This was an amazingly easy experience to get a good product and cover my “new to me” car. I had read good reviews of Select Auto Protect. David Richman had the right attitude and sense of humor to be clear about the product and how to explain it. We were able to reach an agreement, exchange documents and get a warranty to start towards the end of the one offered by the car dealership.

If you are wondering if this is the product for you – my vote is YES! Happy to have 5 years and 60,000 added to the protection on my vehicle. And happy to join team Select Auto Protect.” – Carrie Biggs-Adams

Fenix Protect Reviews

Here are several Trustpilot Fenix Protect reviews. The company currently has a rating of 4.3 out of over 1,300 reviews.

“They were very patient and found every discount or break they could give me on my price they were just very helpful and it seemed like they wanted to give me more for cheap or for less and that always starts out a business deal and trust and devotion to your customer so thank you very much.” – JOSHUA MCGEE

“Excellent customer service. The process was thorough and very easy to set up for the warranty. I had a very friendly agent who made sure I knew exactly what was covered in my policy, when the policy starts, when payments start, and he provided the customer service number in case I had additional questions later. Definitely happy with the experience I had.” – KAMERON LEE


In conclusion, while both Select Auto Protect and Fenix Protect offer extended warranty coverage and roadside assistance benefits, the two companies have some key differences. Based on the comparison in this blog post, Select Auto Protect seems to be a better choice for those looking for an extended warranty. The company’s lower prices, longer contract terms, and better customer reviews make it more attractive. Ultimately, the final choice of an extended warranty provider should be based on individual needs and budget. However, this comparison highlights the strengths of Select Auto Protect and may be helpful for those considering an extended warranty.

Free Quote
No Hidden Fees
Cancel Anytime

We made it easy for you, just follow 3 simple steps

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top