Select Auto Protect vs. Freedom Warranty

Drivers rely on a vehicle’s warranty to protect against the financial burden of unforeseen repairs and maintenance. When an original warranty expires, this critical protection goes away, leaving you at risk for a costly bill from the auto body shop. Extended warranties solve this problem, giving you and your wallet peace of mind in an emergency situation.

Shopping for an extended warranty isn’t always easy, as there are many available plans and providers. Select Auto Protect is one of the best options, and here, we compare our plans against one of our main competitors: Freedom Warranty. Read on to learn more about each company and the coverage they offer so you can choose a plan to fit your needs and budget.

Comparison

Before we dive into the specific details of the Select Auto Protect and Freedom Warranty plans, here is a comparison chart summarizing each company:

	Select Auto Protect	Freedom Warranty
Trustpilot rating	4.5	n/a
24/7 Claims	Yes	Yes
Unlimited Service Calls/Claims	Yes	Yes
Deductible	$100 per claim	$100 per claim
Experience in the Industry	30+ years	10+ years
Money Back Guarantee	Yes (30-Day)	Yes (30-Day)
Cancellation Policy	Full refund if canceled within 30 days of purchase	Full refund if canceled within 30 days of purchase
Roadside Assistance	Included in all plans	Included in all plans
Additional Benefits	Trip interruption benefits Towing coverage Gas refill services Payment plans	Rental car coverageInterest free payment plans
Sample Contract Available	Yes	Not Available

Select Auto Protect Overview

Select Auto Protect offers 24/7 claims processing and gives customers peace of mind through our 30-day money-back guarantee. Another benefit of Select Auto Protect extended warranties is the seamless payment experience. Instead of paying out of pocket for the entire repair bill, customers are only responsible for the deductible. With a quick call to our customer service team, the remainder of the payment is handled directly between Select Auto Protect and your chosen repair shop.

To further reduce the stress and overwhelm that accompanies unplanned auto repairs and maintenance, Select Auto Protect does not require a pre-repair inspection. To start the process, all you need to do is call customer service with your current odometer reading and your vehicle’s VIN number. You may also bring your car in for repairs at any ASE (National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence) location across the United States.

Pros and Cons

Here are some of the main Pros and Cons for Select Auto Protect:

Pros	Cons
Coverage for vehicles of all ages	Newer to the extended warranty industry
24/7 claims	No mobile app
Seamless reimbursement and repair payment process
No onsite inspection required

Freedom Warranty Overview

Freedom Warranty was founded in 2015 and is based in Chattanooga, Tennessee. The company offers their products through authorized retailers, such as auto dealerships, lenders, insurance agencies, and repair shops. Currently, their plans are offered in 23 states, including Washington D.C.

Unlike some warranty providers, Freedom Warranty is the sole provider of their services, meaning they do not use a third party. The company prides itself on customer satisfaction and offers plans covering vehicles of all makes, models, and ages. Freedom Warranty also offers extended warranty coverage for vehicles up to 200,000 miles. 

Pros and Cons

Pros	Cons
Five plans to choose from	Must purchase through an authorized partner
24-hour helpline	Lack of transparency on website
Coverage for older/high mileage vehicles	Negative BBB reviews

Select Auto Protect vs. Freedom Warranty: Coverage

Here is a summary of the plans and coverage for Select Auto Protect and Freedom Warranty.

Select Auto Protect Coverage

At Select Auto Protect, customers can choose from three comprehensive extended warranty plans: the basic Select Silver plan, Select Gold, and the highest tier plan, Select Platinum. Select Silver is ideal for customers on a budget and protects essential components, like the engine, cooling system, brakes, and electrical components. The middle tier Select Silver plan includes all benefits from Select Gold with additional coverage for your steering system and lockouts. 

Select Gold is the highest tier plan which includes all benefits from the Gold and Silver plans plus coverage for your AC and cooling system, ABS brakes, suspension, and more. All Select Auto Protect customers benefit from additional helpful perks, like emergency roadside assistance, gas refill services, and a rental car program. 

	Select Platinum	Select Gold	Select Silver
Engine	x	x	x
Transmission	x	x	x
Cooling System	x	x	x
Brake System	x	x	x
Electrical System	x	x	x
Drive Axle	x	x	x
Trip Interruption	x	x	x
Gas Refill	x	x	x
Roadside Assistance	x	x	x
Rental Car	x	x	x
Lock Out	x	x
Steering System	x	x
ABS Brakes	x
AC System	x
Heating System	x
Fuel System	x
Turbo/Supercharger	x
Hi-Tech	x
Front Suspension	x
Back Suspension	x

Select Auto Protect Cost

The actual cost of a warranty depends on several factors, including your vehicle’s age, mileage, and make and model. The average price for coverage with Select Auto Protect is between $1,300 and $2,000 in upfront costs, however this could vary depending on your own unique situation.

Freedom Warranty Coverage

Freedom Warranty has five comprehensive plan options. Each of the plans are for specific vehicle ages and mileage amounts. 

One of the main disadvantages of Freedom Warranty is the lack of an option to purchase coverage directly. If you’re interested in buying one of the company’s plans, you’ll need to go through an authorized partner. 

Freedom Warranty Cost

As mentioned above, the actual cost of your extended warranty depends on several factors. Currently, there is no pricing information available online for Freedom Warranty. Potential customers are encouraged to work with an authorized partner to obtain a custom quote.

Customer Reviews

In order to get a more accurate picture of what coverage with each company is like, here are several customer reviews for both Select Auto Protect and Freedom Warranty.

Select Auto Protect Reviews

On Trustpilot, Select Auto Protect has a 4.4 out of 5 star rating out of over 130 reviews. Here’s what real customers had to say about Select Auto Protect.

Many thanks to Russel Walker for his expertise in helping me sign up for a service warranty for my Mercedes-Benz. He explained all aspects of my warranty in an easy-to-understand, concise manner. – Donna

Select Auto Protect made it the smoothest process handling my claim I had through them for my cars repairs. I didn’t have a car during the repair so Select was able to provide a rental which was awesome and helped me out so much. The claim was approved so easily, and Select paid for the claim before they even started the job! My direct account representative, Matt Ryan, was amazing with helping me and making sure everything was handled for me. Its very rare to have customer service like this these days, but Select Auto Protect has proven that there are good people out there. If you are skeptical about getting a warranty after horrible experience elsewhere, this is the company you are looking for! – anonymous

Freedom Warranty Reviews

Freedom Warranty is not listed on Trustpilot, however it is listed on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website. The company currently has a rating of A+, however it has a customer review rating of 1.92/5. The average star rating is two out of five from a total of 13 customer reviews. Here are some of the positive comments:

Honestly I was worried at first about having to submit a warranty claim. I have usually had nothing but issues, and pushback. This was the smoothest warranty claim I have ever had to deal with. They mainly worked with my service advisor and everything was approved in a timely manner. Great service thank you guys! – Amanda S.

FIVE STARS….They made my situation right and they worked on it with customer care….totally awesome would recommend to ALL.. Personable and quick with reimbursement check. They worked on my claim due to a 2 time deductible , on which since my vehicle wasnt fixed the first time and was taken back to shop, so upon my explaining of the 2 time fix was because wasnt fixed t he first time , so I was not charged a second deductible. FREEDOM ROCKS!! Now gonna get mom on it . PEACE AND HIGHLY RECOMMEND. – JD

Unfortunately, most of the customer reviews under Freedom Warranty on the BBB website were negative. Here’s what customers had to say:

This company is not a good choice of warranty! I purchased a warranty for my son and I cancelled it within 30 days bc my husband and I had one on our daughter car and when we needed to use it it didn’t pay the entire claim! I asked for a refund and they wouldn’t give one! Please don’t buy this warranty it is no good! – Tawanna

Something does not feel right about this company. Do your homework before buying. Ask for and read the full contract and ask questions before buying. They did not answer any of my questions and this is the response I got from them. “After consulting with my team leader, we came to the conclusion that Freedom isn’t the right fit for you.” I find that very interesting. Are they trying to hide something? I guess they are looking for people who do not read the fine print. – Doug B

It is worth noting that a Freedom Warranty representative responds to most of the negative reviews and works to resolve each issue. 

Conclusion

Shopping for an extended warranty involves a great deal of research and consideration. Taking the time to review all of your options will help you make the most informed purchase decision. Select Auto Protect and Freedom Warranty are reputable companies with comprehensive plan options if you’re in the market for an extended warranty.

While Freedom Warranty has a high rating with the BBB, it has a significant amount of negative customer reviews. If you’re interested in purchasing a Freedom Warranty plan or obtaining a quote, you may only do so through an authorized partner. Select Auto Protect offers similar coverage with the convenient option to obtain a quote online or by speaking with a customer service representative over the phone.

The Select Auto Protect team has over 30 years of professional experience in the automotive industry. Our favorable Trustpilot rating and countless positive customer reviews speak for themselves and you can rest assured your vehicle is in good hands. Contact our friendly customer service team today to obtain a quote and learn more about the benefits of a Select Auto Protect extended warranty.